CNET Editors' Rating: 2.5 / 5
The good: Apple's Maps app finally has functional turn-by-turn directions with voice. 3D Flyover views are very impressive in supported cities.
The bad: Generic search terms bring up inadequate results. Many locations we tested lack details. Flyover produces strange visual bugs when browsing some areas. Public transit directions are no longer part of the app.
The bottom line: Apple Maps now has functional turn-by-turn navigation and gorgeous 3D Flyover features, but lack of public transit directions, shoddy details on maps, and distorted 3D views in some areas make this app mostly unusable until there's an update.
Design, Features & Performance (out of 10)
Coming as a part of iOS 6, the Apple Maps app has received a lot of bad press for good reason. Out of the gate, Apple's replacement for the Google-powered Maps app in iOS 5 has a lot of problems. Simply put, this app is not an upgrade over the last version of Maps.
One feature that many people have been waiting for on iOS devices is now here in Apple Maps: turn-by-turn directions with voice. Using the Siri assistant as its voice, the app performed adequately in our testing on the streets of San Francisco. It delivered us to the place we wanted to go, and the voice directions gave us plenty of time for turns with few problems. The app had some hiccups when it came to rerouting, attempting to send us back to our original path rather than giving us a route on the new direction we were traveling (though it corrected itself soon after). It also had a problem with the difference between two contiguous streets with slightly different names (e.g. Broadway and West Broadway) -- a small difference, but important when you're traveling in a new city. Still, the turn-by-turn directions performed well overall, but that's not all there is to a mapping app.
Location search and map details
Where the Apple Maps app is lacking are in search and map details. In our testing around our offices and when viewing well-known landmarks, we found several locations that turned up almost no details, where Google Maps showed much more useful information. As an example, a plan view of the San Francisco International Airport showed only the three main terminals, where on Google Maps you get shops, restaurants, services, and even an interface element that lets you switch floors within the terminal. The app also doesn't do well with generic searches like "coffee" or "pizza," giving some results, but nowhere near what you see on the Google-powered maps in iOS 5. We often don't compare an app directly to another in a review, but in this case, Google Maps is what was on the iPhone in iOS 5 so a direct comparison is fair.
No guidance for public transit Another feature lost with the new Maps app is trip planning that includes public transit. Where you used to be able to get directions with the option of viewing the best route via bus, train, or otherwise in iOS 5, in the new app you're only given a list of apps currently in the iTunes Store that might help you. This is a huge oversight because a large number of people use public transit (or they should) and leaving these features out of the app means environmentally responsible travelers are out of luck.
The 3D Flyover mode is another new feature in iOS 6 and it is definitely impressive if you're looking at specific cities. The app has several areas modeled in full 3D, letting you swipe to fly over buildings or use a two-finger gesture to rotate, and it looks beautiful with smooth frame rates even on last-generation devices. But the feature is not without serious problems. When looking at some areas, visual bugs such as airport runways with bumps like a roller coaster and streets that startlingly drop off vertically are only a couple of many examples where the new feature falls short. I also wonder how much you'll actually use the feature beyond showing off to your friends.
The Apple Maps app is the company's first effort at creating a maps app, so I didn't expect it to be perfect, but I also didn't expect it to have this many problems. As much of the information is crowd-sourced (with user-driven information from Yelp), the app should get better over time. With all the bad press, there's no doubt Apple is working right now to update the app, but until it does, people who have updated to iOS 6 have few mapping options. While there has been talk of Google making a standalone app for iOS, it's unclear whether you'll be able to get a Google Maps app on your iPhone in the near future. Unfortunately, as is, Apple Maps is not an improvement over the previous Google-powered app and you might be better off using a third-party maps app or Google's Web-based offering through your phone's browser.
|Category||Navigation and maps|
Average User Rating: 2.5 / 5
User Rating Breakdown
5 Star: 1
4 Star: 0
3 Star: 0
2 Star: 1
1 Star: 1
Potential to be a good, but not ready yet
Rating: 1 / 5
on October 15, 2012
0 out of 0 users found this review helpful
Pros: * nice graphical interface with turn-by-turn driving function
*3D maps is neat but not necessary
Cons: * Does not work well for city folks as there is no inclusion of integrated public transportation
* The words "east" and "west" don't work properly. This is especially a problem in NYC where this is critically necessary.
Summary: Apple maps adds some nice ads from Google Maps, but it simply does not work correctly in some places, rendering it completely useless. If you have the option to retain your Google Maps and not "upgrade" to Apple maps, I highly recommend you do so.
* Does not work well for city folks as there is no inclusion of integrated public transportation
* Something is wrong with Apple's algorithm and the words "east" and "west" don't work properly. This is especially a problem in NYC where this is critically necessary. The maps program simply has no idea where an address like "10 west 83 street" is located
A nice to have feature but very limited and buggy.
Rating: 1.5 / 5
on September 26, 2012
0 out of 0 users found this review helpful
Pros: On the flow fast 3D rendering.
Cons: * very few places in 3D
* Bugs here and there
* a replica to google maps.
Works very well in the St. Louis, MO area
Rating: 4.5 / 5
on September 25, 2012
0 out of 2 users found this review helpful
Cons: Wish flyover was available on 3GS but oh well
Summary: Media hype doesn't apply to St. Louis, just wanted to point that out. May be different elsewhere, but not here. Personally, it wouldn't surprise me if it was way overblown.