Google Android 4.1 Jelly Bean
CNET Editors' Rating: 4.0 / 5
The good: Android 4.1 Jelly Bean enriches several main features like notifications, Voice Search, and Android Beam. It also speeds up performance.
The bad: It isn't clear what you can and can't say to Google's voice search. Offline dictations are notably less accurate, and there are fewer camera modes in stock Jelly Bean.
The bottom line: You won't be left too far behind without it, but Android 4.1 Jelly Bean is a worthy update that brings improved voice search, notifications, and sharing.
Design, Features & Performance (out of 10)
Google made a massive splash in more ways than one at its Google I/O 2012 developer conference. Not only did it unveil its new Nexus 7 tablet and Nexus Q entertainment device, it pulled the wraps off of the software powering it all, Android 4.1 Jelly Bean.
Besides having a delicious name, Jelly Bean features a whole host of upgrades including smoother handling, a fresh look, a more intuitive UI, camera enhancements, and new voice search prowess rivaling Apple's Siri. Now we know many Android smartphone users are still stuck in Android 2.3 Gingerbread-land, yet to experience the joy of Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich. Once you see what Jelly Bean can do, you'll want to hopscotch right past ICS and make Android 4.1 your mobile home.
Interface and unlock
Google has made a few subtle changes to the OS interface, just enough for you to tell it's a different operating system as soon as you unlock the phone. The unlock screen on stock Android 4.1 adds some animated rings around the unlock icon, and now lets you unlock to the Google Search app.
There are also a few more wallpaper options, including the slightly more pastel look that Google showed off in its I/O conference demo. With Jelly Bean, Google filled in the search bar, presumably to keep it in sight, and therefore in mind. Google also removed the unsightly grid guides you see in Android 4.0 when you drag a widget or icon onto the screen (whew). Another subtle addition is the extra security layer of blinking to Android's 4.x face unlock feature.
Perhaps Google was inspired by Samsung's TouchWiz UI or even Microsoft's upcoming Windows Phone 8 start screen because Jelly Bean's new resizable widgets feel very familiar. For example, you can alter the size of some application widgets when you place them on any of the Nexus' home screens (five in all). Just long-press the widget and brackets will appear around it that you can drag bigger or smaller with your finger.
Of course there must be enough room on the screen for you to do this. Jelly Bean will help to create more space if it's possible by automatically pushing app shortcuts out of the way to clear a path. We found this new Android capability useful, though it's only certain widgets, such as Gmail, Calendar, and Google+, that can perform the trick.
One new awesome widget we fell in love with is Song Search, which does for Android's home screens what integrated song ID does for Windows Phone. It's a simple thing that doesn't offer the depth of third-party apps like SoundHound or Shazam, but it does return results after you hold the microphone to the speaker. Tap that result and Jelly Bean will deftly sell you the single from Google Play.
Google gets a gold star for integrating notifications deeper into the operating system. Pull down the notifications shade to see a list of your alerts and activities that now have interactive elements that let you do things like respond to missed calls right from the screen, share screenshots, view the weather, and so on.
We weren't able to see any images shared via Google+ (still working on that one), and collapsing and expanding the notifications can be tricky, since the wrong move will dismiss them instead. Google has room to fine-tune the beefed-up notifications, but we do like the additional context.
Android phones have earned a bad rep over the years for exhibiting clunky, even stuttering performance at times compared with the silky-smooth operation of Apple's iOS devices. With Jelly Bean, Google has taken steps to squash these criticisms. The company launched a new initiative called Project Butter while crafting the new Android update. Its sole purpose was to speed up animations, menu navigation, and overall phone performance.
We can definitely say we notice the difference on our Samsung Galaxy Nexus Jelly Bean test unit. From the moment we placed the phone in our hands it was easy to see and feel its increased agility. Menus, apps, and home screens opened and closed instantly. The contrast was especially clear when we performed the same operations side by side with a Galaxy Nexus (Verizon) running Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich. This Nexus with its older OS was less responsive in practically every way, taking slightly longer to flip through home screens, launch the app tray, and fire up applications.
Of course we suspect that Google has made Jelly Bean's graphics more efficient, which means you shouldn't expect to see an uptick in raw number-crunching performance. Quick Linpack benchmark tests (multithread) confirmed this. Equipped with identical 1.2GHz dual-core TI OMAP 4460 processors, the Nexus phones logged essentially identical scores (72.049 MFLOPs, Jelly Bean; 71.227 MFLOPs, Ice Cream Sandwich). Similarly, running the FPS2d benchmark, a test that measures 2D graphics performance, the two Galaxy Nexus handsets notched the same 58 frames per second.
Behind the scenes, Jelly Bean also promises faster, more-efficient application updates that only rewrite the portion of the code that's changed, so you don't have to wait while the OS overwrites the entire application each time.
Camera and Gallery
Jelly Bean brings a few notable changes to the stock Android camera application, though they really center on the interface. Instead of the traditional static camera app screen, which mostly relies on finger taps to manipulate photos, the Android 4.1 shooter uses a new filmstrip view. To pull up the gallery of saved images, just swipe your finger to the left (we can thank Microsoft for this behavior in Windows Phone). While you can flip through photos the tried-and-true way (dragging fingers left and right), pinching the screen widens your view and opens the filmstrip.
Not only will the filmstrip allow you to scan multiple images and videos at once, you can quickly delete unwanted content with a quick finger flick upward, sending its corresponding vignette unceremoniously to the trash. Don't worry, though, you can quickly resurrect it by tapping the undo button in the bottom-right corner of the screen. All in all, it's a more elegant and intuitive UI, and it makes the camera more enjoyable to operate.
One feature we would have liked to see, however, is a burst mode or continuous-shot feature, which many smartphones have begun to include -- notably the Samsung Galaxy S III and HTC One X. Still, just like in its Ice Cream Sandwich forebear, you can snap pictures in Android 4.1 while the camcorder function is rolling.
While Google explained that its virtual keyboard in Jelly Bean offers a more accurate dictionary for better word prediction, we haven't noticed significantly enhanced performance. Of course it'll likely take time tapping out texts and e-mails for us to truly see if Jelly Bean has a greater gift for choosing our words. As for the keyboard's layout itself, it sports the same key pattern and spacing found on pure Ice Cream Sandwich handsets. It makes for comfortable, if no-frills, typing.
Just like Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich before it, Jelly Bean can listen to your voice and convert it to text. We found the feature to work very well, consistently transcribing our spoken words accurately. It even turned our guffaws into hilarious "ha ha"s.
New to Jelly Bean is its ability to do these voice typing functions offline without a data connection. Unfortunately, offline dictation was less accurate when we tested in Airplane mode, with the Galaxy Nexus tripping up over sentences that it handled easily when its cellular or Wi-Fi radio was engaged.
The popularity of Apple's Siri voice assistant may be the root cause of Google's revamped Voice Search app, but Google has acquitted itself very well in this department nonetheless. The app opens easily and fairly quickly with a swipe up from the bottom of the screen. Voice Search doesn't seem to be picky; we were able to drag it open on the Galaxy Nexus by swiping up from each navigation button.
There are several interrelated parts to the app, which can get confusing to describe, but they all fit pretty well together in the real world. The important parts are the search bar, which lets you talk to type your query, and a bunch of blocks of text and graphics. The latter "cards" are actually part of Google Now (see below), so we'll start by focusing on the Voice Search makeover.
You can tap any microphone icon systemwide or say "Google" to trigger a voice search. Either launches a new screen marked by a pulsing red microphone, your cue to speak up. While you talk, a pattern of gray blocks lets you know the app is listening. There's not much delay between the time you stop talking and the time it starts computing, and we did get cut off once or twice. However, Google's Voice Search showed some good accuracy, which is hard to come by in this stage of voice recognition software. Of course, the computer's mistakes and misinterpretations still plagued us.
We used our voices in a range of scenarios to search for images, facts, dates, location, and stories on the Web. Most of the time, Google's search got it right, even for slightly longer queries. The app returns Web links, thumbnail images followed by Web links, or those aforementioned cards with neatly contained answers about how high a building is, a celebrity's birthday, a country's capital, and so on...followed, of course, by a thick stack of Web links. It's good to see that Google hasn't forgotten its heritage.
If you have the phone's media volume turned on and you ask a question that the app can answer with a card, it will also read the answer aloud. When Google search returns images or just a stack of links, it remains silent.
Since the new Search App puts a fresh coat of paint on previous Voice Actions, there are still the usual commands to set an alarm, call a contact, play a song, and get driving directions. However, Voice Actions are a little more rigid and without a prompt for what you can say, it won't be as easy to set that calendar appointment or cancel an unwanted alarm.
If the big question on your mind is whether Google's new Search look can beat Siri, the answer is still somewhat up in the air. Remember that all Google did was make interface changes that spotlight its Voice Search and make it easier to call up from any screen. The nuts and bolts remain the same as in Android 4.0.
Since Google Now is tied into the new Google Search app, you might be tempted to think of it as part of Google Siri-like voice assistant -- but it isn't. Instead, Google Now is the name of an optional feature that periodically checks your GPS, calendar, and search history so it can predict your commute times, suggest eateries nearby, keep track of your favorite teams' scoreboard, and so on. There's an entire list of trackable items, and you can adjust the settings for each category on the ever-present card motif.
Google Now will seem clunky at first, and that's because the feature learns over time. In the short period we've had Jelly Bean, we haven't been able to establish the kinds of habitual routines that Google Now needs to really take the pulse of your life. Thankfully, for all its Big Brother knowledge about your goings-on, Google Now doesn't come across as a creepy omniscient presence, and, in fact, we're finding it helpful so far. The weather report is always convenient, and we do relish the public transportation schedule and appointment reminders.
We're eager to see how accurately Google Now handles our lives, but have to reserve our final judgment. For now, we're taking some time getting to know each other to see where the features shine and stumble.
Google Play updates
Google Play has had movies for some time, but our Jelly Bean device and the Nexus 7 tablet are the first to include full movie downloads, in addition to brand-new content types -- magazine sales and TV show downloads. Google is making up some lost ground behind Apple's more mature content store, but it's a move that will please many. Rentals all come at a price, and Google intelligently gives you multiple download options, including HD quality for a dollar more. So, a movie may cost $3.99 to rent, but $4.99 to rent in HD. If you buy it outright, it could cost $11.99. Not all rentals are available for purchase, and prices vary per flick.
Similarly, TV episodes rent for $1.99 for individual episodes; a season could cost between $24.99 and $34.99, or more for the HD version. Prices once again vary by show. Magazines follow the same model, with the option to subscribe for the month or year, or to buy a one-off edition. Bon Appetit, for example, costs $1.99 per month, $19.99 for the year, and $4.99 after the fact (or as we like to call it, airport-style).
Google is just getting started with these newer forms of content, so you won't find absolutely everything you want to get under your eyeballs. Google does do a nice job featuring certain titles, but it also organizes content by category and top sellers, and lets you search.
We bought some magazines and a TV episode in a seamless process, since we have a Google account outfitted with a credit card. It's even easier if you have the option of carrier billing.
Android Beam update
We're huge fans of Android Beam, but we like it even more now that Google has followed Samsung's lead with S Beam, which was the first to handily share larger files like photos and video from one NFC-enabled phone to the other. Now with Jelly Bean software, every NFC-enabled Android phone will be able to do it, too.
Despite arriving less than a year after Ice Cream Sandwich, Android 4.1 Jelly Bean thankfully comes with a raft of meaningful additions that go far beyond the simple bug fix and performance tweak. There are plenty of those, too, but the real benefits are easy to see, and make a difference when using a phone. The new voice search experience and Google Now deliver a one-two punch that will, at the very least, make Android users feel much more engaged with search, especially since the new pull-up gesture gives you voice search access anywhere.
Although we're not sure exactly how well it works yet, or how useful it will be on a daily basis, Google Now is at least a novel feature that uses the right tools to predict the information you may want to know about your schedule, your commute, your travel information, your climate-related comfort, and your favorite teams. That's something Apple doesn't offer. Unfortunately, it isn't always clear what kind of script you have to follow to make voice actions happen, so Siri's more flexible language engine wins there.
Notifications, a brawnier Android Beam, and a smoother photo-viewing process make Jelly Bean a worthy upgrade from Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich, and the OS to lust for if you're still using Android 3.2. However, Google's work is far from done, and there are some additional fixes we'd want made in order for Jelly Bean to really rule the candy shop.
Average User Rating: 4.0 / 5
User Rating Breakdown
5 Star: 4
4 Star: 0
3 Star: 2
2 Star: 0
1 Star: 4
The worst update I have ever had.
Rating: 0.5 / 5
on March 25, 2013
2 out of 2 users found this review helpful
Pros: New Google
Cons: No Speed Dial
No Sleep Mode
Apps are not working
Heating UP to well over 100 degrees
Shorter Battery Life
Widgets not working
Summary: This update does not work on DROID RAZR phones. I know that I am not the only person with these problems. My phone performed the update on its own and I wish it had not. I suggest that no one updates their phones with this software. I may have to go find a different phone because my phone doesn't work with this update.
worth it for the G-Nex
Rating: 5 / 5
on June 29, 2012
1 out of 1 users found this review helpful
Pros: More responsive, better graphics, and I love the improvements to the notifications.
Cons: The adjustments to the keyboard take some getting used to. I haven't really used it enough to have found any major problems.
Summary: It's a lot like the 2.2 to 2.3 update, not a "major" update like 2.3 to 4.0, but if your used to 4.0 you WILL see the difference.
Absolutely perfect! Best mobile OS by far.
Rating: 5 / 5
on July 16, 2012
1 out of 2 users found this review helpful
Pros: Extremely fluid transitions. Improved notifications. Still has free wifi tethering on Nexus. Enhanced mobile security. Beautiful UI. Face to unlock is more useful and secure. Improved camera app. Buttery smooth operation improves apps. GOOGLE NOW.
Cons: HTC still has a better media player with Sense, but Google Play Music management online is solid- outside the phone. Camera app trails TouchWIz and Sense in features/filters. Sense lock screens are superior. Higher learning curve than competition.
Summary: Jelly Bean is fluid, crash free, and very, very fast. Ice Cream Sandwich was already fast and fluid, but if you used a phone with a skin on top of it, the crashes would definitely come and eventually, you would have to do a reset. HTC Sense would rack up memory space and constantly send data back and forth unnecessarily, and of course the bloatware was present. Like all Nexus phones, Jelly Bean is pure Android, no bloat, no filler. That said, it has beautiful transitions and is polished to levels that make Gingerbread (and skins) look clunky. The expanded notifications are very helpful, although it took me a minute to figure out that you need to use TWO fingers to expand the notifications for greater depth of information. Also, the "clear all" button has changed from an "X" to some weird stacking graphic that isn't clearly apparent what it does. That brings me to the issue that Jelly Bean is STILL not as easy to use and figure out as iOS and WP7. Is it more powerful? Yes. Is it more flexible? Yes. Is it as intuitive? Absolutely not. This is NOT a smartphone for great grandpa or your 4 year old child. For those with an iQ over 90, it will be a breeze. Google still needs to make things more obvious (like with floating/disappearing LABELS).
That said, The UI is gorgeous and the polish is spot on. The multi-tasking button actually CLOSES apps now, where in the past it simply pulled them off the "recent apps" list. The notifications are superior to anything else out there as you can actually control your phone's functions like hanging up the phone or silencing alarms directly from the notification shade.
Google now is very functional, very accurate, and the voice is perfect. It's much more useful than Siri, although it lacks Siri's sarcasm and some of the pleasantries that Apple's voice command system has. It's more useful, but won't make you laugh or feel good. You'll use it more than Google's Voice Commands or Apple's Siri, since the process is very refined. The cards are clean and easy to read. One side effect is that in Google Navigation, currently Jelly Bean uses TWO voices. The clean sweet voice, and the last robotic voice. It's jarring at times, but still gets the job done. They really need to get the Google Now voice to be the only voice.
Maps is much improved, and one thing they made better was when Android is giving directions, if you have music playing at the same time, the music will dim. The only thing that doesn't quite work is that the Galaxy Nexus has a weak external speaker, so Android's voice doesn't come through very well, even with the temporary lower music volume. They need to increase her voice while they lower the music volume. Regardless, Maps/Navigation is still best in the business with 3D flyovers and Street view.
I could go on, but most of the features are covered in length in the CNET review.
One last note. Go Launcher EX works terribly with JB. It becomes laggy and sticks at points. If you want to switch up launchers, use Nova or Apex. They keep JB's buttery smooth operation and you can place widgets from the app drawer which you couldn't with Ice Cream Sandwich.
Updated on May 6, 2013
Can't stand the complexities of the file system.
Rating: 0.5 / 5
on June 26, 2013
0 out of 0 users found this review helpful
Pros: Too disappointed to worry about the pros.
Cons: Sftp's files directed to the Download folder by Turbo Client are invisible to the "Download" viewer.
Summary: Have now wasted a full day trying to figure out why my new HTC ONE X can't be used in any simple way. I didn't want to have to learn a whole new operating system to use what should be a consumer friendly device. Previous HTC Desire worked fine. Turn on storage mode and home free.
Worse upgrade I have ever done
Rating: 1 / 5
on June 12, 2013
0 out of 0 users found this review helpful
Pros: None I want my old phone back with Ice Cream Sandwich
Cons: Disabled the free FM Tuner and replaced it with data sucking slacker. phone freezes, Alarm is not dependable, Touch screen is ridiculous, camera is horrible, the keyboard and auto spell check is infuriating. Sound quality is beyond crappy.
Summary: Like the previous poster the phone updated on its own. I wish it never had. This is the worst update since windows millennium! With Ice Cream Sandwich the Electrify 2 was an awesome smart phone with Jelly Bean it is just another data sucking battery draining piece of junk. I used FM Tuner daily and it was a deciding factor for my purchasing the Motorola Electrify 2 a year ago. I think customers should be better educated on exactly how an update is going to change their device so they can make an informed decision or allow a feature to roll it back to the previous android version. Its becoming more and more evident that there is no such thing as free anymore as everything must have some level of monetation attached to it. I have advised everyone I know NOT to upgrade to Jelly Bean because all it does is riddle the phone with data sucking decay.